Last week, Google posted an update to their Webmaster Central Blog announcing a mobile algorithm update rolling out in May of this year. The update is said to increase the effect of the mobile-friendly ranking signal in order to “help users find even more pages that are relevant and mobile-friendly.”
Google goes on to explain that if you’ve already made your site mobile-friendly, you shouldn’t worry:
“If you’ve already made your site mobile-friendly, you will not be impacted by this update.”
If you missed Mobilegeddon last year, I’m impressed. It was a big deal in the digital marketing industry and a very real example of how neglecting your online presence can impact your business.
With that said, the fallout from Mobilegeddon was lackluster at best. Mockingbird can’t be the only SEO/digital marketing company that is feeling like a boy cried wolf.
Needless to say, we will be keeping a close eye on the impacts of this pending update and assess whether or not we can ever trust that boy again…
Is Mobile-Friendly That Important in Legal?
YES! In case you’re still not convinced that having a mobile-friendly/responsive website isn’t important despite Google making such a fuss, than consider this:
According to ComScore, people using a regular ol’ desktop computer to search peaked in 2013. Each following year, desktop searches have declined. I can’t imagine someone getting in a car accident, receiving a DUI, or seeking legal advice regarding a terrible work situation waiting until they make it home to start looking for a lawyer. Not to mention the effort involved in firing up the old Gateway computer (they don’t make those anymore) to start hammering on a mechanical keyboard (they do still make those) to find the perfect attorney.
I can, however, imagine them pulling out their awesome new Galaxy S7 Edge (which they haven’t turned off since buying it) to do a quick mobile search and call directly from the SERPs.
Overall vs. Google Desktop Search Volume in US (MM)
If your legal website is responsive, give yourself a pat on the back. If it’s not, there’s no time like the present to make you and your law firm more accessible to the people trying to find you. If you need help, we’re happy to chat: 206-209-2125.
Now, if I were a bettin’ man I would put money on the possibility that Google might roll-out a similar update for a more secured web…
Legal Marketing SEOs have been saying it for years: “Content is King”. We’ve blamed the failure of our clients marketing efforts on the clients: “the reason your site isn’t delivering is because you aren’t writing enough content.” “You need to blog more.” “Your site is SEO’d, you just need to write more.”
Here’s the dirty secret: there is plenty of legal content out on the web. In fact, I dare you to find a piece of legal content that doesn’t have over 100 pages on law firm websites optimized for it. Its not the content stupid. Hapless SEOs still keep blaming their failures on their clients’ unwillingness to vomit out vapid content onto the blog on their SEO’d sites. (I still don’t know what an SEO’d site is btw.)
Worse: your die-hard commitment to churning out dull prose about yesterday’s car accident on the intersection of Main and Walnut, is most likely hurting your site’s performance. YES – content hurts – and the mind numbingly dull news rewrites being dumped into blogs on a daily basis pollutes not just the internet as a whole, but the ability of your site to generate traffic… traffic from people who are looking to hire you for your car accident expertise, instead of the slip and fall accident reported first in the Local Herald back in November of 2012.
Seems that all of those SEOs exhorting you to write more have forgotten about the apparently forgotten… Panda. The penalty that looks for dull, thin, poorly written garbage content and enacts a site-wide penalty – which hits the few good pages you do have.
How to Tell If (Google) Thinks (Most of) Your Content Sucks
What follows is overly simplistic – but as we’ve looked at data from hundreds of law firm sites, the following pattern has emerged. Simply do a site:mywebsite.com search and see how many pages are indexed and then use Google Analytics, filter by natural traffic only, then look at: Behavior – Content – Landing Pages and count the number of pages that are generating inbound traffic over the past three months. (Now this assumes you don’t have any ridiculous technical errors auto-generating duplicate versions of your content.)
In the graph below… note the outlier down at the bottom right hand corner. This law firm has invested thousands of dollars barfing vapid content at a regular pace of 4 posts a week for the past two years. They wanted to know if… if… they should continue their content strategy (I shudder to actually write “content strategy”). And yet – over the past 3 months more than 82% of their pages had not delivered a single visitor. I plotted a few of our long-term regular clients to provide some perspective – other sites saw between 25% and 88% of their pages generating SEO visits (and you can bet we aren’t pushing more content to that one site sitting at 25%). Note that it is not just volume of content – one site with close to 900 pages has almost 60% of them driving visits.
So…. if you find the ratio of pages to landing pages below the 25% benchmark… perhaps your problem really is content. Too much of it.
In his blog post yesterday, local SEO guru Mike Blumenthal reported on click-to-call phone numbers now showing in mobile organic searches. What does this mean? Essentially, along with the normal website link and description, Google is now testing out clickable phone numbers directly in the search results for mobile searches. Let’s look at some examples from Mike’s blog post…
In this example, the user was searching for AC repair businesses in Corpus Christi, Texas.
The user was searching for local jewelers in Buffalo in this screenshot.
So what happened when I tried to replicate the click to call numbers for legal related search queries? (I’ll give you a hint: it worked.)
My search for “criminal defense attorney buffalo, ny” produced the click-to-call feature on page 3 of the results.
In this example, you can see the click-to-call results on page 2 of the results for the query “dui attorney spokane wa”
Here’s what we know:
The change was first noticed on February 29, 2016.
Google is likely testing this feature – clickable phone numbers are not yet showing on the first results page (usually a solid sign this is a Google test).
This is likely to be a mobile-only update.
They are testing the new click-to-call feature in most service business searches, including legal search queries.
Why is this change significant?
It might not be. Most likely, this is just another test by Google to see how they can improve their user’s experience. We’ve seen mobile organic tests (remember colored separators on mobile?) like this before that never made it to the big stage. However, if this clickable phone number as part of the snippet is ultimately implemented across the SERPs (search engine results page) and not just sitting quietly on page 2, 3, or 4, there could be some major implications, both negative and positive.
Potential implications:
As an SEO, it’s not only fun, but also my job to speculate on the potential impact of Google’s tests. So what could this click-to-call change mean?
Increased conversion rates. By removing one step for the user, they should be more likely to call your business.
More holes in lead tracking. Much like in the local pack results, businesses probably won’t be able to use call tracking for the click-to-call number, thus creating a hole in lead reporting.
NAP consistency will be key (with an emphasis on the P). If you have multiple conflicting phone numbers on your website – a common blunder in the legal industry – Google will be more likely to either display the incorrect number or not show your phone # at all for the click to call option.
Check back for updates – we’ll keep an eye on this for you.
One of the things I learned early on when analyzing website traffic to law firms was that it fluctuates on a weekly, not monthly pattern – with low traffic on weekends, and high traffic on Mondays the tapers down over the work week. Yet most agencies and law firms use monthly reporting.
Jagged traffic patterns to law firm websites.
Granted, monthly reporting is frankly, extremely convenient, as most vendor billing cycles are monthly as well – and most tools report on these monthly cycles as well. Unfortunately, its extremely inaccurate. Yesterday’s leap year day will have automagically generated an additional 3% increase in February’s 2016 vs 2015 traffic. On a typical non-leap year, the number of days in March is 10.7% more than February. And it’s not just February – as months have small changes in the number of days (or the number of weekends making up those days), the subtle changes hides real performance when looking at month-to-month traffic changes.
This is why we run all of our reporting on 4 week Periods…. a much more accurate approach to monitoring subtle changes in website traffic patterns (no explanations of, “well, last month only had 8 weekend days…”). It also means we sit down with our clients 13 times a year to review benchmarks and progress, instead of the typical twelve.
Expect your PPC campaigns (and therefore probably your SEO traffic) to go a little haywire this week. Google has abruptly rolled out a very large change to the search engine results page (SERP) interface…. removing all ads (and apparently everything) from the right rail – see Siberia below.
Here’s What We Know
The changes impact desktop searches only.
There are now four ads above natural search results and three below.
The changes only impact “commercial” queries – presumably most of the more transactional legal terms, but probably less so for queries researching a particular issue (see example below).
The change is permanent (for now).
What it Means (I think)
Clearly pushing more ads above natural search is going to shift traffic from organic to paid…. SEO players lose, PPC players gain (and so does Google.)
In the already overpriced legal PPC market, there’s even more competition for just 4 prime spots (remember, SERPs used to have up to 11 ads, including most legal queries) which is going to drive up already irrational (read: unprofitable) PPC bidding among lawyers.
(Smart) lawyers will look to diversify their paid marketing channels – driving up bids in Bing. (For more on the economics of this see my 2013 post – Google Adwords Costs 150% More than Bing Ads.)
Local now becomes even more important for lawyers (and remember, it was just August when the number of local results constricted down to the three firm “snack pack”.
In summary, there are fewer ads total; however, they take up more of the prime real estate – which impacts both natural and paid results.
Those lovely stars showing up in the SERPS…. just might be fading away…. starting on February 15, the number of queries that returned results with review snippets has dropped by roughly one third. Barry Schwartz at Search Engine Land posits that this may just a bug, not a feature change and Google hasn’t responded to questions about it. Furthermore, I can’t imagine reviews are going to decline in impact for local results AND asking your customers to crow about you online is still a best (marketing) practice – so I wouldn’t change anything at the moment.
Here’s the drop-off visually from Moz’s SERP feature tracker:
UPDATE: Looks like this was indeed a bug over at Google:
From an outsider’s perspective, business location management is hardly considered a problem. For the unfortunate marketers and SEO’s doing the leg work, location data management is often a major issue. The most straight forward solution to fixing your business listing’s consistency across the web is to outsource to a third party provider, such as Yext. Tools like this have the capacity to simultaneously manage thousands of online business locations at once.
Google’s recent partnership with Yext grants all businesses the power to manage virtually every aspect of their location data. Yext mentioned that instead of having to worry about simply finding and correcting problems, the Google My Business API allows businesses to think about their data not only as data, but as a marketing tool. In other words, they can start utilizing and interacting with data rather than just reacting to what their data is representing.
The Google integration permits immediate data changes, such as special holiday business hours or unplanned closures. However, it’s important to note that while you can implement these changes immediately, Google has the final say over when your changes are actually published.
Google explained in a blog post last December that through the new Google My Business API, developers can:
Create business locations with information such as name, address, phone number, category, business hours, and more
List, invite and remove managers on locations and business accounts
Read listing state to identify Google updated, duplicate and suspended locations
Search/Filter locations by name, category and label
Set the service area for a business either by specifying a point and radius or Place IDs
In part six of Mockingbird’s “Toolbox Webinars” series, we’ll walk you through the two most popular local business management tools: Moz Local and Yext. Learn why just buying these tools isn’t enough, why you need both of them, and more about Yext’s newly forged partnership with Google – a service previously only available to agencies and large buyers.
If you want to learn more about utilizing Yext for optimizing your local web presence, sign up for our webinar today!
In the world of legal marketing, we see a general push from our clients to have more than one website. We constantly see law firms with a website for each practice area, or, in this case, separate websites for general use and PPC landing pages. So we reopen the age-old debate – should your law firm have more than one website, specifically for PPC vs non-PPC purposes?
Separate domains for PPC landing pages
When running PPC campaigns, we’ve heard the experts urge us to have landing pages that are relevant and specific to the content mentioned in your add. But how to you integrate that content into your existing site, if it’s not there already? This dilemma becomes increasingly difficult when you are running more and more PPC campaigns – where do you put these pages?
An answer some are turning to – separate domains. For example, these sites below. On the left is the law firms “normal” website, on the right, their PPC website.
Four Reasons to Have One Website for Your Business
Google says so. Google does not like duplicate content. It has said so here. And if you weren’t convinced, Google releases algorithm updates like Panda that beat sites with duplicate content into a pulp. By having two websites discussing your law firm and a specific area of practice (lemon law, in this case) you’re bound to have nearly identical content. There is only so many ways you can say “we will help you with your lemon law case.”
You’ll get more traffic. Having two websites is means you’re self-cannibalizing your traffic. Business school beat “synergy” into me – the idea that 1 + 1 can sometimes equal 3. The same concept applies here. Sure, you get traffic on your main site. And you get traffic on your PPC landing pages site. But chances are, if you consolidated the two, you’d get more traffic than the sum of them separately. And more traffic -> more clients -> more money -> happy you.
Improve your ROI. The more websites you maintain, the more money you spend. You need to buy each additional domain, pay for hosting,
Better user experience. Imagine this: your car sucks, desperately you do a Google search for a lawyer. You click a brilliantly constructed ad, and get taken to a site relevant to your search query. It’s all good so far. But then, you, the not-dummy you are, decide to poke around this site. Sure, there’s some content, but it seems weak. So you leave this crappy website because it doesn’t quite seem legit.
Consolidate Your Websites and Live a Longer, Happier Life
Seriously. Just do it. You’ll save money, probably see an uptick in traffic, and build some karma in the Google Gods book.
Picture this hypothetical website disaster: You are completely overhauling the website for your law firm. You switch domains, implement a beautiful redesign, and migrate all the content from the old site to the new one. One week after launching your new site and pulling the plug on the old one, you notice your traffic has dropped off a cliff and you’re not getting any calls.
The decrease in traffic is probably because some of your old pages no longer load. This causes 2 significant problems for your website.
When a page is removed, all the authority it has built up is wasted. On the other hand, new pages don’t have any authority, even if you intend for them to replace old ones. If you don’t let search engines know which of your pages are replacements, they’ll treat those pages like strangers, giving low rankings and little traffic.
Prospective clients who visit your site by following a link somewhere on the web won’t want to pick up the phone if that link leads to an error page (or nothing at all). Even if you’re getting a significant amount of traffic, broken pages will prevent that from turning into leads because users are more likely to bounce off your site when they land on a page that doesn’t tell them anything.
Thankfully there is a way to avoid these kinds of traffic-killing disasters. We do this by using URL redirects.
This is what a 404 page looks like on our website. If you landed here while browsing or clicking a search result, would you want to pick up the phone right now? Probably not.
What are URL Redirects?
A URL redirect is an instruction for computers that tell them a webpage has been moved from its old address to a new one. When a computer (such as a prospective client’s PC, or Google’s web crawler, etc.) visits a page with a redirect, it will be automatically sent to the new destination instead of their old page.
This is valuable for users who are attempting to visit a page that has been moved or deleted. Normally a page that doesn’t exist would show an error such as “404 File Not Found”. However, with a redirect you can instruct computers to automatically load the new location of your page, or a related page instead. Now instead of losing a prospective client because you sent them to a blank page, you increase the chance that someone will engage with your site and subsequently contact your firm.
Redirects can also help your performance with search engines. If an old page has built up authority with search engines (in English: a lot of people link to it) but then one day it disappears, you’ll lose all the “link juice” that page provided to your site. Setting up a URL redirect will point search engines to a real page, preserving most of the authority you garnered with Google and keeping your traffic healthy.
When you use redirects, any computer that visits your old page will get directed to your new page instead.
Building Blocks of a URL Redirect
While the concept of a URL redirect is constant, the tactical implementation changes for different websites. You might have to declare your redirects on every page individually, put them into a single file, or work with your host’s custom system. Because there is a vast number of ways to set up URL redirects, a comprehensive guide on the topic is outside the scope of this article.
However, there is some common ground for redirect implementation. No matter where or how you implement a redirect, you will always use 3 key pieces of information. Those pieces are:
Source
Destination
Type
The building blocks of a redirect. It’s like legos, except on the internet.
Source
The source is the page you don’t want users to see. To write out the source, take the web address that you no longer users to visit, and remove the domain along with everything that comes before it. For example, if we were implementing a redirect with the source:
https://mockingbird.marketing/some-deleted-page/
The domain of our site is mockingbird.marketing, so we remove it and are left with this:
/some-deleted-page/
This would be our source, and we would write that down.
Destination
The destination is the (live and working) page you want to send users towards. Declaring this is as simple as writing down the web address of the desired page. If we were implementing a redirect with the destination
https://mockingbird.marketing/new-page-location/
Then we would just write that.
Type
Redirects come in 8 or 9 types and each one has a different technical reason why it will be used. However, you can learn 2 redirects and use them essentially 100% of the time. These have status codes and nicknames, both of which are good to know:
301 – “Permanent”: This is the ‘normal’ redirect, and it should be your go-to option. A 301 redirect does everything we talked about above.
302 – “Moved Temporarily” or “Found”: A 302 redirect is very rarely used. It works as expected most of the time, but search engines ignore 302 redirects for the purposes of assigning authority. Use 302 redirects only if you plan on using them temporarily, like if you need to do website maintenance.
Regular Expressions?
Sometimes you may have to redirect a lot of pages at once. Instead of writing every redirect separately, you can make a “bulk” redirect. For example, if we were migrating from an old website:
https://pelican.marketing/
To our current one (“mockingbird.marketing”), and every single page on the old site was the same except for that domain. We might write a source like this:
^/(.*)/?$
And our destination would be:
https://mockingbird.marketing/$1/
Regular expressions are technical, and using them incorrectly can break your site. They’re beyond the scope of this article, but if you want to learn more about regular expressions then you should check out the Resources section below.
In this post we talked about how URL redirects can save you from a possible disasters by engaging viewers and preserving traffic from search engines. We looked at redirects on a basic level, and what information to start gathering when you want to create your own redirects. Proper use of URL redirects can keep your web traffic (and your bottom line) safe.
Resources
If you want to learn more about regular expression and URL redirects, here are some resources that we’ve found useful.
webconfs.com has a list of ways to declare 301 redirects in different languages or by using htaccess files. These are some of the different tactics we mentioned earlier.
Moz has another good description of redirects, along with instructions for implementing 301 redirects in Apache.
Dave Clements of DoItWithWP has a simple introduction to regular expressions (about as simple as it can get).
WPEngine has a list of common syntax used in regular expressions, along with examples.
RegexPal lets you test if your regular expressions work. In order to use it properly, you will also have to treat all forward slashes (looks like this: “/”) as special symbols like “^“, “$“, “.“, and “?“.