• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to content
  • Skip to footer

Mockingbird Marketing

Marketing Agency for Lawyers

  • About
    • About Us
    • Meet Conrad Saam
    • Market Exclusive
    • 1% For Good
    • Careers
  • Services
    • Search Engine Optimization
    • PPC Advertising
    • Web Design & Development
    • Reporting for Law Firms
  • Resources
    • Scan My Business
    • Top Results
    • Case Studies
    • Escape FindLaw
    • AdWords Under $1000
    • Legal SEO Store
  • Events
  • Blog
  • Contact
206.209.2125

Analytics

Are Your Partners Sending Fake Traffic?

Posted on: March 8, 2016 by Conrad Saam

Estimated reading time: 3 minutes

At the risk of stating the mind-numbingly obvious: accurate reporting infrastructure is of primary importance in evaluating the efficacy of marketing channels.  We’ve recently uncovered two vendors deep in the conversion cycle, whose reporting infrastructure is double and even triple counting website traffic. (This artificially made our own reporting to the client  look much better than it actually was.)

The Issue

The issue at hand is the way conversions are reporting back to Google Analytics data. A good reporting infrastructure is built not only on traffic – but also the frequency of that traffic doing what we want – in the law firm sense, this means (for the most part) filling out an online form or calling the firm.  We’ve looked at two different cases in which both online and offline conversions are being counted as a second or even third session, which means over reporting traffic.

Apex Chat (Online Conversions)

In the case of Apex Chat, we found that when sending chat completion data (as a conversion event) back into Google Analytics, Apex actually sends a new session to GA when chat is engaged and another new session if the chat moderator marks the chat as a prospect.  These are marked as events in Google Analytics as:

  • ApexChat Chat
  • ApexChat Lead

This means, a session generating a lead is erroneously reported as three different website visits. If you dig deeper into those sessions – you see (in the graphic below) them applied to Direct traffic and that they see zero pages and zero time on site.   You’ll also notice – in this case they inflate direct traffic volume by 6%.  Not huge numbers, but not insignificant if you are watching things as closely you should.

Apex

This is simply a very sloppy integration with Google’s API – Apex told us they are aware of the issue and have a resolution; although they didn’t roll it out to us when we requested.

CallRail (Offline Conversions)

The CallRail issue is more difficult, because frankly tracking an offline conversion back into an online reporting system is tactically much more difficult.  Essentially, the phone number identifies the channel that generated the session; however, tying the call back to the specific session is much more difficult. (The work around is to utilize CallRail’s per session based phone tracking, a significantly more expensive alternative.)  But you can see, given the sheer volume of calls generated by a website, that there’s a large inflation of sessions – in this case, they are accurately allocated to the appropriate marketing channel – so traffic for all channels gets artificially inflated.  In our example, this was a sitewide artificial increase of 9%.  In the graphic below, look at the dramatic difference in patterns between the inaccurate (first column of graphs) and accurate (with the duplicated traffic removed) second column of graphs.

CallRail

For now, I’ll reject my internal cynic and reject the hypothesis that some especially crappy agencies are deliberately implementing tools to artificially boost their numbers….. or, hmmmm, maybe I’ve just enabled them with the information to do so.

Sign up for our Newsletter!

10 Things You Should be Doing vs 10 Things You Must STOP Doing

April 23, 2018 - 12:00 pm PST - Seattle, WA
Learn More

Reader Interactions

Footer

Ready to grow your legal practice? We are! Let's Chat.

Mockingbird:

We focus exclusively on helping attorneys and law firms market their services to clients. With experts in PPC, business reporting, technical SEO, design & development, and content. If you need it done, we have someone who can do it.

Find Us:

512 2nd Ave #200
Seattle, WA 98104
(206) 899-0226

Resources:

Featured Resources
Services
Upcoming Events
Mockingbird Blog
Need a quick fix? Check our Legal SEO store…

Echo Marketing Platform:

More of a do-it-yourselfer? Just starting out? Echo is your solution. Get a website and SEO + online marketing tutorials with industry standard tools at one low monthly cost. Learn more.

Twitter / Facebook / LinkedIn

Mockingbird Marketing © 2013-2018. All Rights Reserved. | Privacy Policy | Site Map